(I’m not linking the song that shares this title. I’ve never liked REO Speedwagon)
Yesterday’s piece, comparing the 25 vs. 50-basis point question facing the Federal Reserve to the “will they / won’t they” decision in a formulaic romantic comedy, must have put an ‘80’s power ballad into my head. Regardless of the source, I have been forced to reckon with the nagging suspicion that tomorrow’s FOMC meeting has the potential to be a major “sell the news” event.
As I type this, the markets have not fully coalesced around a consensus outcome for the rate decision. The CME FedWatch currently shows a 60/40 split in favor of the larger cut, though that is down from 70/30 yesterday and earlier today. Meanwhile, the IBKR ForecastTrader shows a 72% chance that the rate will be set above 4.875% tomorrow. Normally there is sufficient guidance from the talking heads at the Fed that those probabilities approach 90-100% for a given outcome. Thus, we go into this FOMC meeting with far less clarity than is typical.
Over the past few days, I’ve been laying out my case for why I favor 25bp over 50bp. Yesterday I offered four reasons, noting:
- We saw price pressures in the Payrolls and CPI reports,
- The Fed doesn’t like to surprise markets
- Political considerations ahead of an election
- The very reasonable change that the Summary of Economic Projections shows an economic forecast at odds with investor expectations and/or rate cut projections are more modest.
Furthermore, a week ago, when expectations strongly favored a 25bp cut, I offered the following extra considerations:
- As for the “monetary policy is too restrictive” argument, my retort is “based upon what?” A stock market that is in spitting distance of all-time highs? A corporate bond market that absorbed $80bn in new issuance in three days this week without blinking? We’ve all become liquidity addicts, hoping desperately for a fresh dose whether we really need it or not.
- Someone asked me … if the soft-landing narrative is in peril. I’m not sure why (especially given the paucity of precedents for them). The AtlantaFed GDPNow model projects 2.1% GDP growth [it’s now 2.5% as of today]. That is indeed consistent with a soft landing. An unemployment rate of 4.2% is something historically enviable, though it is indeed above its lows. And if we should doubt a soft landing, how can we expect double-digit earnings growth for the S&P 500 next year?
As I read through these this morning, I still believe that the Fed should still lean to 25bp. But years of trading experience has taught me to respect the message of the market, and that message has been saying 50bp. A long-time market watcher reminded me this morning that it is unlikely that the Wall Street Journal’s Fed whisperer would have penned a story that left the door open to 50bp – during a quiet period, mind you – that didn’t reflect the message that the central bank wanted to portray.
Yet that’s where the problems may come in.
Of course there will be widespread disappointment if the Fed opts for 25bp. Equity markets always crave more liquidity, and at the same time, bond markets have all but priced in an aggressive rate cutting path for future meetings. The smaller cut would bias against both.
But what if we get 50bp? Much depends upon the messaging.
- If it’s 50bp and a clear statement from either the FOMC and Chair Powell that the economy is fine but they are embarking on a path to quickly normalize restrictive short-term rates, then markets should do OK. But again, is monetary truly restricting investment activity? It is quite possible that they indicate that a larger cut might be all about getting the ball rolling but hedge on the necessity of future cuts. Remember that rates are quite high by the standards of the period since the Global Financial Crisis, but that both nominal and real rates are relatively normal over a longer historical scope.
- But if it’s 50bp because the Fed tells a dire picture about the economy, or alternatively, is so sanguine about the economy that they have little interest in cutting rates at the pace implied by markets (5 cuts in 2024 and another 5 in 2025), then that would be a negative regardless.
Finally, assuming we close at the levels we see at midday, it would be seventh straight up day for the S&P 500 (SPX). That is a long streak and implies that a significant amount of good news has been priced into equities. The Fed will need to deliver even more good news to keep exuberant equity traders happy.
Join The Conversation
If you have a general question, it may already be covered in our FAQs. If you have an account-specific question or concern, please reach out to Client Services.
Leave a Reply
Disclosure: Interactive Brokers
The analysis in this material is provided for information only and is not and should not be construed as an offer to sell or the solicitation of an offer to buy any security. To the extent that this material discusses general market activity, industry or sector trends or other broad-based economic or political conditions, it should not be construed as research or investment advice. To the extent that it includes references to specific securities, commodities, currencies, or other instruments, those references do not constitute a recommendation by IBKR to buy, sell or hold such investments. This material does not and is not intended to take into account the particular financial conditions, investment objectives or requirements of individual customers. Before acting on this material, you should consider whether it is suitable for your particular circumstances and, as necessary, seek professional advice.
The views and opinions expressed herein are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the views of Interactive Brokers, its affiliates, or its employees.
Disclosure: Forecast Contracts
Forecast Contracts are only available to eligible clients of Interactive Brokers LLC, Interactive Brokers Hong Kong Limited, and Interactive Brokers Singapore Pte. Ltd.
Disclosure: ForecastEx
Interactive Brokers LLC is a CFTC-registered Futures Commission Merchant and a clearing member and affiliate of ForecastEx LLC (“ForecastEx”). ForecastEx is a CFTC-registered Designated Contract Market and Derivatives Clearing Organization. Interactive Brokers LLC provides access to ForecastEx forecast contracts for eligible customers. Interactive Brokers LLC does not make recommendations with respect to any products available on its platform, including those offered by ForecastEx.
I would like to fund my account but I need to talk to someone.
What is the phone number to call for funding account ?
Thank you
Hello, thank you for reaching out. Please create a web ticket or start a live chat with Funds and Banking: https://spr.ly/FundAccountcampus
Also, you can use this tool on our website to review available funding methods, ETAs, and any associated fees based on your residency and the currency you wish to deposit: https://spr.ly/FundAccountcampus
Please reach back out with any additional questions. We are here to help!
You’ve never liked REO Speedwagon? C’mon Sos, that song is basically what being in the stock market is all about, right?
The bond market says 50bp but since it does not matter much whether they do 25 or 50 because they are still doing more before year end it makes sense to give what the bond market already has said that rate decrease should be 50 bp. They can always wait an extra month before doing more.
I’ve never liked REO either. Bubblegum music. Good call
.
I must be the only one who still studies charts. S&P case-shiller National Home Price Index at 320.818! CPI & PPI at record levels. DOW and S&P sitting at record levels with the Nasdaq lagging just behind. I really don’t think it’s the appropriate time for rate cuts.
absolutely agree.
The only song of theirs I liked. I never liked Prince either, but I like one of his songs. I hate country music, but I love a few country songs. Tap music is toxic, however…blablabla.
Therefore I have a feeling tomorrow’s stock movement will not be important. Because nobody cares about my opinion.
The music at Texas Roadhouse is awful but I like the food so I wear earplugs.
Everybody is saying Sell the News event which means the market will rally to all time highs tomorrow (maybe after an initial dip)