Bitcoin futures, which Cboe Global Markets and CME Group hope to list later this year, may accomplish what the global financial crisis could not: decimating a slew of trading firms and threatening the stability of Wall Street’s clearing outfits.
No single listed financial product has ever caused such mayhem, but Thomas Peterffy, one of the world’s most successful derivatives traders, is concerned that Bitcoin derivatives will introduce extraordinary volatility into the market that will be difficult to contain. “For the first time, I am extremely scared,” says Peterffy, founder and chairman of Interactive Brokers Group (ticker: IBKR).
JPMorgan Chase’s (JPM) Jamie Dimon and BlackRock’s (BLK) Laurence Fink worry that Bitcoin is a bubble and a money launderer’s best friend. Peterffy has a different concern: He fears that low margin rates will encourage speculation, endangering trading and clearing firms.
Futures margin rates range from 2% to 8%. When an investor’s losses exceed that range, brokers must immediately cover them, then try to collect from the client. This year, Bitcoin has traded from about $708 to almost $7,400. It could go higher, or it could collapse by 70% in a day. It’s hard to analyze the price because Bitcoin has no economic function, unlike commodities such as corn or futures on the Standard & Poor’s 500 index.
Peterffy worries that small trading firms will offer the lowest margin rates to attract business, thus becoming weak links in the market’s defenses against risk, such as that posed by various products that track the CBOE Volatility Index, or VIX. Many investors are betting that the VIX will stay low. That wager could prove catastrophic if volatility suddenly surges, and stocks fall.
“The weaker clearing members charge the least. They don’t have much money to lose anyway. For this reason, most Bitcoin interest will accumulate on the books of weaker clearing members who will all fail in a large move,” Peterffy says.
Peterffy wants the CME (CME) and the Options Clearing Corp., or OCC, to limit clearing members’ liability for peers at $100 million for Bitcoin futures. He also wants to isolate Bitcoin from other financial products, a step he says already has been taken for some volatility products. Interactive Brokers will offer Bitcoin futures trading if those conditions are met, and consider stopping doing business with some clearing firms if they’re not.
CME, Cboe (CBOE), and the OCC wouldn’t comment, other than to say that the risk of Bitcoin futures is manageable.
IN MANY WAYS, Bitcoin futures exemplify the challenges U.S. exchanges face. Once, markets were where companies managed risk or raised capital. Now, equity-oriented exchanges are essentially very fast computer systems, built to appeal to high-speed and quantitative traders. Commodities exchanges like the CME depend on trading volume in their listed products.
Nothing the exchanges have dealt with has caught the public imagination like Bitcoin. So, at a time when banks such as Goldman Sachs Group (GS) are reporting that clients aren’t interested in trading stocks, bonds, and derivatives, exchanges must pursue Bitcoin. Trading fees could be huge if the Commodity Futures Trading Commission allows the Cboe and CME to list Bitcoin futures.
The situation should humble the derivatives industry, which struggles for mainstream acceptance. “Investors are willing to commit millions, tens of millions, and hundreds of millions into Bitcoin,” says Vincent Au, a portfolio manager at hedge fund Gondor Capital, “yet people are scared of options.”
It has been said that Wall Street develops new financial products by throwing ideas against a wall, and trading anything that sticks. Bitcoin futures, if Peterffy is right, could bring down the wall.
Steven M. Sears is a Senior Editor and Columnist with Barron's. He is the author of "The Indomitable Investor: Why a Few Succeed in the Stock Market When Everyone Else Fails." Mr. Sears previously reported for Dow Jones Newswires and The Wall Street Journal. He has reported upon most major modern financial events, including the Asian Contagion, the bursting of the Internet Bubble, the Credit Crisis, and Europe's sovereign debt crisis. He also was part of exchange executive teams that modernized the U.S. options market, and introduced electronic trading. Interact with him on Twitter @sm_sears.
Get investing analysis that moves stocks and markets—Subscribe to Barron’s for just $1 a week.
This article is from Barron's and is being posted with Barron’s permission. The views expressed in this article are solely those of the author and/or Barron's and IB is not endorsing or recommending any investment or trading discussed in the article. This material is for information only and is not and should not be construed as an offer to sell or the solicitation of an offer to buy any security. To the extent that this material discusses general market activity, industry or sector trends or other broad-based economic or political conditions, it should not be construed as research or investment advice. To the extent that it includes references to specific securities, commodities, currencies, or other instruments, those references do not constitute a recommendation by IB to buy, sell or hold such security. This material does not and is not intended to take into account the particular financial conditions, investment objectives or requirements of individual customers. Before acting on this material, you should consider whether it is suitable for your particular circumstances and, as necessary, seek professional advice.
We appreciate your feedback. If you have any questions or comments about IB Traders' Insight please contact firstname.lastname@example.org.
The material (including articles and commentary) provided on IB Traders' Insight is offered for informational purposes only. The posted material is NOT a recommendation by Interactive Brokers (IB) that you or your clients should contract for the services of or invest with any of the independent advisors or hedge funds or others who may post on IB Traders' Insight or invest with any advisors or hedge funds. The advisors, hedge funds and other analysts who may post on IB Traders' Insight are independent of IB and IB does not make any representations or warranties concerning the past or future performance of these advisors, hedge funds and others or the accuracy of the information they provide. Interactive Brokers does not conduct a "suitability review" to make sure the trading of any advisor or hedge fund or other party is suitable for you.
Securities or other financial instruments mentioned in the material posted are not suitable for all investors. The material posted does not take into account your particular investment objectives, financial situations or needs and is not intended as a recommendation to you of any particular securities, financial instruments or strategies. Before making any investment or trade, you should consider whether it is suitable for your particular circumstances and, as necessary, seek professional advice. Past performance is no guarantee of future results.
Any information provided by third parties has been obtained from sources believed to be reliable and accurate; however, IB does not warrant its accuracy and assumes no responsibility for any errors or omissions.
Any information posted by employees of IB or an affiliated company is based upon information that is believed to be reliable. However, neither IB nor its affiliates warrant its completeness, accuracy or adequacy. IB does not make any representations or warranties concerning the past or future performance of any financial instrument. By posting material on IB Traders' Insight, IB is not representing that any particular financial instrument or trading strategy is appropriate for you.